Heretics

image source: http://www.panmacmillan.com.au/display_title.asp?ISBN=9780330535861&Author=Storr,%20Will

I’ve decided to stop playing games and pick up books again. My daughter is 10 months old and is imitating everything I do, and I want her to stop patting my 3DS and pick up a book instead. My unread pile isn’t very huge, but didn’t look too appealing. So I made a quick trip to my favourite bookstore and picked up a few new books. Richard Dawkins’ autobiography was one of them. Heretics, by Will Storr, was another. I’m less than a 100 pages in but already liked it enough to write about it.

Heretics is a kinder book than the ones I’m used to. Storr tours the world, meeting people with.. odd beliefs, from creationists to UFO nuts. Anyone who (like me) has spent hours arguing with friends and family on skepticism, the placebo effect, rationality and so on, will notice how stubborn and defensive people can get when pushed to a corner. The facts don’t matter to them, and perversely, make them less inclined to change their minds. It’s not often you see a mind changed when faced with convincing data.

An excerpt stood out, early in the book:

I consider — as everyone surely does — that my opinions are the correct ones. And yet, I have never met anyone whose every single thought I agreed with. When you take these two positions together, they become a way of saying, ‘Nobody is as right about as many things as me.’ And that cannot be true. Because to accept that would be to confer upon myself a Godlike status. It would mean that I possess a superpower: a clarity of thought that is unique among humans. Okay, fine. So I accept that I am wrong about things — I must be wrong about them. A lot of them. But when I look back over my shoulder and I double-check what I think about religion and politics and science and all the rest of it… well, I know that I am right about that… and that… and that and that and — it is usually at this point that I start to feel strange. I know that I am not right about everything and yet I am simultaneously convinced that I am. I believe these two things completely, and yet they are in catastrophic logical opposition of each other.

The book goes on to explore why otherwise intelligent people delude themselves into believing things that are so obviously not true to the rest of us. Well worth a read (so far). As a plus, the book is also a lot funnier than I expected, and there’s more than one laugh-out-loud moment when Storr undergoes some excruciating ritual or the other to get into the minds of these people.

Tagore on critics

The manner in which literary analysis is engaged with in our country is completely uneducated. There’s no point in hearing: ‘I liked it’ or ‘I didn’t like it’. That only gives you a particular person’s opinion; it doesn’t give you the truth of that opinion. If that opinion comes from somebody who is sufficiently capable of appreciation or experienced in literary affairs then even that might make you think a little. But just any person’s opinion has no value at all. Our country lacks good reviewing skills—and the primary reason is that the people of our country do not have an intimate acquaintance with literature.

Pale Fire Review

I bought this at a used book store a few weeks back. It is a worn down, old edition from the 1960’s. This is my third Nabokov book, and ever since my first, I seem to have lost interest in the ‘normal’ fiction books I used to read. There is a cadence to his choice of words that shines through in all his works.

The story is told by Charles Kinbote, a hilarious, clueless, nosey neighbour of famous poet John Shade. Shade, dead when the story begins, has been working on a 1000 line poem titled Pale Fire. Kinbote hails from the fictitious land of Zembla, and pesters Shade with stories of its rich history and its last King. He is clearly shattered when he gets his hands on the draft of the poem after Shade’s death, and sees nothing related to this.

Things go crazy from here. Bent on seeing what he wants to see, Kinbote annotates the poem with rambling connections that he draws to his own Zemblan theme. Liberally drawing his own inferences from the rough drafts, the picture that emerges is of a man imposing his delusions on another’s work.

The Unreliable Narrator trope has been done to death in movies already (Rashomon, Fight Club, Memento, American Psycho, The Usual Suspects…), but Nabokov has layered his work with magnitudes more of easter eggs. Saying more would spoil the fun, and I’ve already seen several interpretations online that I missed in my first reading.

I cannot speak for   the poem itself, having very little exposure in that area. The story, however, is Nabokov at his playful, devious best. The liberally cross referenced footnotes make for a rich experience over multiple readings.

Enhanced by Zemanta

Ignorance and bliss

A quote I read a long time back in some book resurfaced in my memory yesterday, and thankfully, I remembered enough keywords to track it down in the first attempt. Full credit to Aristotle the Geek, where I found it in full. The book was William Durant’s ‘The Story of Philosophy’. Here is the story itself:

The Good Bramin

Does happiness result from ignorance or from knowledge?

IN my travels I once happened to meet with an aged Bramin. This man had a great share of understanding and prudence, and was very learned. He was also very rich, and his riches added greatly to his popularity; for, wanting nothing that wealth could procure, he had no desire to defraud any one. His family was admirably managed by three handsome wives, who always studied to please him; and when he was weary of their society, he had recourse to the study of philosophy.

Not far from his house, which was handsome, well-furnished and embellished with delightful gardens, dwelt an old Indian woman who was a great bigot, ignorant, and withall very poor.

“I wish,” said the Bramin to me one day, “I had never been born!”

“Why so?” said I.

“Because,” replied he, “I have been studying these forty years, and I find it has been so much time lost. While I teach others I know nothing myself. The sense of my condition is so humiliating, it makes all things so distasteful to me, that life has become a burden. I have been born, and I exist in time, without knowing what time is. I am placed, as our wise men say, in the confines between two eternities, and yet I have no idea of eternity. I am composed of matter, I think, but have never been able to satisfy myself what it is that produces thought. I even am ignorant whether my understanding is a simple faculty I possess, like that of walking and digesting, or if I think with my head in the same manner as I take hold of a thing with my hands. I am not only thus in the dark with relation to the principles of thought, but the principles of my motions are entirely unknown to me. I do not know why I exist, and yet I am applied to every day for a solution of the enigma. I must return an answer, but can say nothing satisfactory on the the subject. I talk a great deal, and when I have done speaking remain confounded and ashamed of what I have said.”

“I am in still greater perplexity when I am asked if Brama was produced by Vishnu, or if they have both existed from eternity. God is my judge that I know nothing of the matter, as plainly appears by my answers. ‘Reverend father,’ says one, ‘be pleased to inform me how evil is spread over the face of the earth.’ I am as much at a loss as those who ask the question. Sometimes I tell them that every thing is for the best; but those who have the gout or the stone—those who have lost their fortunes or their limbs in the wars—believe as little of this assertion as I do myself. I retire to my own house full of curiosity, and endeavor to enlighten my ignorance by consulting the writings of our ancient sages, but they only serve to bewilder me the more. When I talk with my brethren upon this subject, some tell me we ought to make the most of life and laugh at the world. Others think they know something, and lose themselves in vain and chimerical hypotheses. Every effort I make to solve the mystery adds to the load I feel. Sometimes I am ready to fall into despair when I reflect that, after all my researches, I neither know from whence I came, what I am, whither I shall go, or what is to become of me.”

The condition in which I saw this good man gave me real concern. No one could be more rational, no one more open and honest. It appeared to me that the force of his understanding and the sensibility of his heart were the causes of his misery.

The same day I had a conversation with the old woman, his neighbor. I asked her if she had ever been unhappy for not understanding how her soul was made? She did not even comprehend my question. She had not, for the briefest moment in her life, had a thought about these subjects with which the good Bramin had so tormented himself. She believed from the bottom of her heart in the metamorphoses of her god Vishnu, and, provided she could get some of the sacred water of the Ganges in which to make her ablutions, she thought herself the happiest of women.

Struck with the happiness of this poor creature, I returned to my philosopher, whom I thus addressed:

“Are you not ashamed to be thus miserable when, not fifty yards from you, there is an old automaton who thinks of nothing and lives contented?”

“You are right,” he replied. “I have said to myself a thousand times that I should be happy if I were but as ignorant as my old neighbor, and yet it is a happiness I do not desire.”

This reply of the Bramin made a greater impression on me than any thing that had passed. I consulted my own heart and found that I myself should not wish to be happy on condition of being ignorant.

I submitted this matter to some philosophers, and they were all of my opinion: and yet, said I, there is something very contradictory in this manner of thinking; for, after all, what is the question? Is it not to be happy? What signifies it then whether we have understandings or whether we are fools? Besides, there is this to be said: those who are contented with their condition are sure of that content; while those who have the faculty of reasoning are not always sure of reasoning right. It is evident then, I continued, that we ought rather to wish not to have common sense, if that common sense contributes to our being either miserable or wicked.

They were all of my opinion, and yet not one of them could be found to accept of happiness on the terms of being ignorant. From hence I concluded, that although we may set a great value upon happiness, we set a still greater upon reason.

But after mature reflection upon this subject I still thought there was great madness in prefering reason to happiness. How is this contradiction to be explained ? Like all other questions, a great deal may be said about it.

Dawkins’ new book is out

I’m a huge fan of Richard Dawkins, and the moment of clarity I got when I first read The Blind Watchmaker is one I’ll always treasure. The world felt sharper, clearer and I walked around in a happy daze for a few days. I’ve read almost all his books since, and loved every one of them.

dawk_thumb

He has mentioned for quite awhile that he’s wanted to write a children’s book, and that book is finally out now. It’s called The Magic of Reality and there are some early reviews out at New Scientist. The book is also, I’m happy to note, already out on FlipKart. Of course, I ordered it immediately. Here’s something to
save for my kids.

Update: A week has passed, and i’m now holding the book in my hands! Maybe I’ll post a review when I’m done.

Signed up for another library

I’ve been a member of Just Books for a few months now, and it is pretty good. The main advantage is that it is walking distance from my place. But they have a pretty decent catalog as well.

After being a member of the British Council on-and-off for the past few years, I signed up to it yet again on Saturday. I took a Platinum membership, which allows six books, three periodicals, and three DVD’s. That still ends up being cheaper than my JustBooks subscription. The membership also gives me online access to their ebrary, which is filled with technical books. That looks like a pretty good option for passing the time.

I now have a lovely box set of Simon Pegg’s Spaced, a couple of Mike Carey and Grant Morrison graphic novels, and a few other fiction and non-fiction books. Good times!