On Nolan’s Odyssey

I wasn’t looking forward to seeing this movie but as someone who grew up on Greek mythology, I suppose I had to. As expected, I was extremely underwhelmed and couldn’t wait for it to finish. Now that the dust (and hype) has settled, I came back to thinking about why I disliked it so much. Nolan is obviously a great filmmaker, and this is a massively hyped and loved movie, isn’t it? Anyway, I thought about it and I think I can articulate what I think is going on:

Nolan. Doesn’t. Like. The. Odyssey.

I don’t have any other explanation for the bizarre choices he made all through the movie.

Why else would he take a fun, vibrant adventure about a wily, charismatic character facing off against one monstrous challenge after the other and turn it into a drab, colourless, joyless story of a soldier’s PTSD from invading another land and killing its people?

Why else would he impose his own shallow morality and world-view on a story told a few thousand years back, when any student of history will tell you that the first lesson of reading historical fiction is to avoid presentism. Note for example how the movie’s Odysseus simply cannot be shown to even partially enjoy his captivity under Calypso. Oh no, Calypso has to be spiking his food and causing amnesia, because our modern audience would be too confused by his behaviour.

Why else would he take powerful women (like the enigmatic and dangerous Circe, or wise Athena) and reduce them to trauma-shocked victims of male violence?

Why else would he remove all the Gods from the story, without which crucial context is missing: Poseidon vows to make Odysseus’ return a misery because of what he did to the Cyclops Polyphemus; Athena however is sympathetic to his plight. Not to mention that incidents like the one with Apollo’s sheep simply don’t make sense without those Gods standing by ready to make good on their curse.

Why else would he constantly harp about unrelated asides (the Sea People; Zeus’ Law) and try to shoehorn them into a forced ’twist’ that he apparently is compelled to use in all his movies? Hey guess what, the Greeks were invading Troy and only a wild, desperate stretch of imagination would compare that to being guests of the Trojans. So, you could hardly say they were guilty of breaking any laws of hospitality by tricking them with a gift horse. By any definition, it was the Trojans who were guests of the Greeks and guilty of breaching Zeus’s law when Paris eloped with Helen. But that wouldn’t fit the narrative would it, we can’t show any complexity, or the audience would get confused.

I am all for each new generation rewriting myths of old (see the Coen Brothers’ O Brother, Where Art Thou? for a better interpretation of the Odyssey, or Dan Simmons’ masterful sci-fi rewrite of the Greek mythologies in Ilium), but this one just left me a bit tired.

If this one-trick pony continues to run, this is how it will all end:


NOLAN

Cast: Christopher Nolan, now in his twilight years. His muse, Mnemosyne, who may or may exist (We need to keep the audience looking for tiny clues debating about something, don’t we).

Nolan in his old age, weathered and tired. Dull, grey colours.

MNEMOSYNE: “You were great once. What happened?”

OLD NOLAN (defiant): “I’m still great. It’s them… They don’t get me anymore. I gave them legends. See how they treat me.”

Flashback to Nolan in his youth, filming Memento. Colours are vibrant. We see Nolan enthusiastically creating meta-narratives, looping stories, and not talking down to his audience.

MNEMOSYNE (voice over): “Where is that Nolan now?”

OLD NOLAN (defiant): “I had my fill with those stories. What captivates me more is stories of powerful characters wracked by guilt. The guilt of Oppenheimer. The guilt of Odysseus.”

MNEMOSYNE: “Guilt? Odysseus had no guilt. He had regret. He cried for the years he lost. He accepted his fate and waged a war he could not escape from, and paid for it with an arduous journey back.”

OLD NOLAN (doubtful): “But the guilt… I saw it…”

Cut to close up of Nolan’s withered face. His famous twist is about to come.

MNEMOSYNE: “The guilt was in you.”

END